Skip to Content

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without … Your Questions Answered (2022)

Wondering if you can make chicken salad without a certain ingredient? Chances are you can, but find out what ingredients you can live without and still have an amazing salad.

title page for post on making chicken salad without certain ingredients

Does this sound like you?

You start making your favorite chicken salad recipe only to realize you are missing an ingredient. An item you thought was essential to the salad.

Should you abandon ship and order take-out? Or can you cobble together the salad without certain ingredients?

This article will teach you all the components of chicken salad that you can substitute or leave out altogether. Don’t worry. You can still have a scrumptious salad even if you don’t throw in a few items on the recipe card.

You may also be wondering if you can serve chicken salad with certain ingredients. Read all about what ingredients you can add to a chicken salad recipe.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Mayo?

You can make chicken salad without mayo and use a substitute instead. Sour cream, yogurt, or any salad dressing are excellent alternatives to mayo.

Softened cream cheese is another choice. Or check out my article on healthier cream cheese options.

Most classic chicken salad recipes call for either mayo alone or combined with other ingredients to make a dressing. Mayo helps keep the salad moist.

Need some bread options for your salad? Read up on the best breads for chicken salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without a Salad Dressing?

Keeping chicken salad moist without some type of salad dressing is challenging. If you want to swap out the salad dressing, try using lemon juice, olive oil, or heavy cream.

These items won’t taste the same as the salad dressing. But they will function the same way by keeping the chicken salad moist.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Dairy?

You can make chicken salad without using dairy (like yogurt or sour cream). Instead, make the salad with a vinaigrette, a combination of oil and vinegar.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Greek Yogurt?

You can easily compose chicken salad without Greek yogurt. In its place, use a mayo/mustard mixture or any type of salad dressing.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Heavy Cream?

You can make any chicken salad recipe without heavy cream. As an alternate, try mayonnaise and mustard, salad dressing, or an oil vinaigrette.

Don’t just make the perfect filling, add the perfect sandwich topping. Get delicious ideas on the best toppings for chicken salad sandwiches.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without High Fructose Corn Syrup?

chicken salad sandwich with arugula

If you want to avoid high fructose corn syrup found in many salad dressings, moisten your chicken salad with sour cream or Greek yogurt, plus a splash of lemon juice. Season with salt and pepper to taste.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Lemon Juice?

Chicken salad does not require lemon juice. Instead, mix Miracle Whip and mustard together to moisten the salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Olive Oil?

Any dairy product, like sour cream, yogurt, or heavy cream, can take the place of olive oil in chicken salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Sour Cream?

You can make chicken salad without sour cream. Use Greek or regular yogurt, mayonnaise, or a vinaigrette instead.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Yogurt?

Most chicken salad recipes do not call for yogurt. Instead, mayonnaise and mustard are the standards. You can also use a salad dressing or a vinaigrette.

Wondering if you can make chicken salad ahead of time? Find out all the tricks for make-ahead chicken salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Sugar?

You can avoid sugar in a chicken salad if you make your own dressing and skip the Craisins. Simple sauces of sour cream and lemon juice won’t have sugar. Beware of Miracle Whip and mayo, which might contain sugar.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Salt?

It is difficult to make chicken salad without any salt. Salt is a key flavor enhancer for chicken and most dressings.

You can make the salad without the salt, but you may find that it tastes bland.

Check out my post on how to make chicken on the stove without drying it out.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Fruit?

chicken salad sandwich on wheat bread

Many chicken salad recipes do not contain fruit. One of the original recipes for the salad had only chicken, celery, and mayonnaise. No fruit at all.

Add dill relish or pickles to the salad, and you won’t even miss the fruit.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Grapes?

Many chicken salad recipes do not call for grapes. Although grapes taste great in the salad, you can substitute dried cranberries or apples for them.

Or skip the fruit altogether and make a savory salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Apples?

Plenty of delicious chicken salad recipes do not contain apples. Apples add a sweet crunch, but they can be swapped out. Try grapes or dried cranberries if you need something sweet.

Add in cucumbers or jicama for a crunch.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Raisins?

Most chicken salad recipes are made without raisins. If you like raisins in your salad but are currently out, try dried cranberries (Craisins) in their place.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Celery?

celery on cutting board

You can make chicken salad without celery. Even though the earliest recipes had celery, you can leave it out. If you need a crunch, try jicama or chopped nuts.

Experiment with peas, corn, or shredded carrots to replace the celery with other veggies.           

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Onions?

It is easy to make chicken salad without onions. If you want the onion flavor, sprinkle in onion powder.

To avoid even the taste of onions, skip the onions and onion powder. Season with salt, pepper, garlic powder, oregano, or parsley.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Olives?

A classic chicken salad sandwich does not usually have olives in it. But a chicken taco salad might. Either way, leave the olives out if you need to. Plenty of recipes do.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Pickles?

You can make chicken salad without pickles. Make a sweet salad instead of a savory one. Add fruits like grapes, apples, and cranberries.  Dress it with poppyseed or honey mustard salad dressing.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Relish?

You can make chicken salad without relish. If you want the same flavor profile, chop some pickles and toss them in. Or you can add dill weed.

If you want to avoid the flavor of dill, go with a sweeter chicken salad with grapes, apples, raisins, or dried cranberries.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Hardboiled Eggs?

Many chicken salad recipes do not have hardboiled eggs. Compose the salad with avocado, celery, mayo, and mustard.                                                                                     

If you do want to use eggs, check out my secrets for getting the perfect soft, creamy hardboiled eggs.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Bacon?

You can make chicken salad without bacon. Although bacon makes everything taste better, your salad can still be spectacular if you don’t want to add it.

If bacon is on your mind, find out the best way to cook bacon in the oven to get crisp or chewy pieces.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Blue Cheese?

Classic chicken salad sandwiches are often made without blue cheese. Taco salads are also.

If you are out of blue cheese or want to lighten the salad, skip the cheese.

Wondering if you can freeze chicken salad? Not if it has certain ingredients. Find out more in the article on how to freeze chicken salad.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Including Walnuts?

bowls of nuts and dried fruit

Many chicken salad recipes do not include walnuts. If you like walnuts but are out, try using a different nut. Pecans, macadamia nuts, almonds, and even peanuts are great alternatives.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Pecans?

Pecans are delicious in chicken salad, but you can make the salad without them. If you still want nuts, try almonds, walnuts, or pine nuts.

Try Instant Pot chicken salad with grapes. No pecans in sight and it is still delicious.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Peanuts?

You can make chicken salad without peanuts. Try it with almonds, walnuts, or pecans.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Almonds?

You can make chicken salad without almonds. Try a different nut or add celery if you still want a crunch.

Many chicken salad recipes do not have nuts. If you do not want to add nuts, skip them.

However, if you want a non-nut crunch, consider adding sunflower seeds, pepitas (hulled pumpkin seeds), or pine nuts (a seed, not a nut).

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Butter?

It is easy to make chicken salad without butter. Cook the chicken with olive oil instead.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Dark Meat?

You can make chicken salad without dark meat. Although dark meat is usually moister and more flavorful, you can use white meat.

Be sure to dress it with a nice salad dressing or vinaigrette.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Pasta?

Chicken salad sandwiches do not have pasta. However, if the salad is meant to be an entrée, you may miss the pasta.

If you want to avoid the pasta, spoon the chicken salad onto a bed of greens. Alternately, mix the chicken with rice.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Rice?

Most chicken salad sandwich recipes do not call for rice. You can make the salad without rice.

Can You Make Chicken Salad Without Bread?

chicken salad served with crackers

You can always make chicken salad without bread. Serve the chicken salad on a bed of lettuce or choose a non-bread alternative.

Crackers, tortillas, and hardboiled eggs are some of the best non-breads to serve with chicken salad.


Did you like this post? Then let’s be social. FOLLOW ME on PINTEREST and INSTAGRAM to keep up with the latest tutorials, favorite recipes, and interesting happenings.